Do I Need Payroll Software or a Payroll Company for One Employee?
October 28th, 2024 | 4 min. read
Updated 11/17/2026
Whether you own a business and have one employee, or you consider yourself the employee as a one-man operation, you’ve found yourself wondering if you need payroll assistance.
It all comes down to whether you need payroll at all (You usually don't if you have no employees as a sole proprietor or independent contactor!), the level of customer service you want, and how comfortable you are with doing payroll on your own.
At CSI Accounting & Payroll, we’ve worked with small business finances for 60 years. That means we’ve addressed a lot of aspects of payroll for one employee, including:
- Whether you need to have payroll.
- Whether you need payroll software for one employee.
- Whether you need a payroll company for one employee.
Do I Need Payroll for Myself?
If you have employees, you need payroll.
But what if you’re self-employed, so the only employee you have is yourself?
Sole proprietors and independent contractors don’t need payroll. This is true because they don’t need to pay themselves, and their taxes are handled outside of payroll. The only exception is if they elect to be taxed as an S-Corporation.
Learn more about self-employed payroll here.
Do I Need Payroll Software for One Employee?
When you have just one employee besides yourself, you may want to try to do your own payroll. Let's compare no software to what software can help you with.
Not Using Payroll Software
Doing your own payroll is possible without the use of any professional software, but we can’t recommend it.
It's easy to forget that payroll is more than just writing checks. Often, people only do their own payroll in an attempt to save money, but it takes a lot more time and effort than it’s worth. It can also result in costly errors.
At the very least, you want to use software.
Using Payroll Software
To use payroll software, most people choose lease it from a big-name payroll software provider.
You still set up and run your payroll, but you have a tool to help with organization and calculations, making it easier to stay in compliance.
However, if not used properly, there are huge limitations with software as a service. It’s not fun to wait in a phone queue for generic guidance if you need help.
(Luckily, there’s an alternative with great customer service: small payroll services. We’ll talk about them a bit in the next section.)
Do I Need a Payroll Service for One Employee?
Is it worth it to work with a payroll company for just one employee?
It can be! If you aren’t completely confident in handling every aspect of payroll on your own, it makes sense to outsource, even if you just have one employee.
Payroll services are very high-value when you consider the compliance they offer and the liability they take off of your shoulders. And you may find better value in small providers than you'd think.
Small providers cost nearly the same as the large providers while handling the setup for you to ensure it’s correct and providing much better customer service.
When you work with a small provider like CSI Accounting & Payroll, you’ll get a dedicated specialist whom you can call, text, or email directly to resolve any issues. They can offer fast, custom advice because they’re familiar with your payroll.
Learn more about the many ways that small payroll providers are different from large providers.
Get Great, Affordable Payroll Service for One Employee!
Now that you know whether or not you need to have payroll, lease payroll software from a large provider, or work with a small payroll service, are you ready to move forward with a small payroll service?
If so, please consider CSI Accounting & Payroll! To see if we can be a good fit for your business, click the button below for a free consultation:
Not ready to talk? That’s okay! First, learn more about what our payroll service can help you with.
Bret is the Operations Manager at CSI Accounting & Payroll, a role he stepped into in 2024. He began his journey with CSI in 2007, starting in a marketing position and eventually becoming the Payroll Department Manager, where he played a key role in helping CSI's expansion and long-term success. His background in sales and management – along with a degree in Computer Networking and Certified Payroll Professional (CPP) title – continues to serve him well in a dynamic environment as he leads the way for our Minnesota office.